Loophole could keep young terror suspects out of US court

FILE – In this Oct. 10, 2017, file photo, the Supreme Court in Washington, at sunset. The Justice Department’s ability to charge minors for supporting terrorist groups has been hampered by a 2018 Supreme Court decision, forcing prosecutors to hand off at least one such case to local authorities in a state without anti-terrorism laws. (AP Photo/J. Scott Applewhite, File)

The Justice Department’s ability to charge minors for supporting terrorist groups has been hampered by a 2018 Supreme Court decision, forcing prosecutors to hand off at least one such case to local authorities in a state without anti-terrorism laws.

The court’s decision in a case unrelated to terrorism opened a loophole that could allow young supporters of groups like the Islamic State to skate on charges from the federal government.

The legal gap was highlighted by the case of Matin Azizi-Yarand , who was sentenced in a Texas state court last month after plotting to shoot police officers and civilians at a suburban shopping mall in an Islamic State-inspired rampage planned to coincide with the Muslim holiday of Ramadan.

Recommended For You

WP GDPR Fix Elite Single Site

The WP GDPR Fix Works with your blog or any other custom implementation of Wordpress including e-com stores. It ensures compliance on 7 key GDPR requirements. Just plug it in and set it up in less than 3 minutes for faster GDPR compliance. It implements

ClickKosh Extreme with Docupanda

Unlimited Domains, Unlimited Brochures, E-Magazines and more!

Viral Image Sharer Standard

Viral Image Sharer 5 Blog Licenses: Early Adopters Launch Special

In most cases like this, federal prosecutors would have brought terrorism charges. But U.S. prosecutors in Texas didn’t charge Azizi-Yarand because he was 17 at the time and considered a minor under federal law.

Federal law allows prosecutors to charge anyone supporting or working with a State Department-designated terror group, even if the person was not in contact with the group. But to charge a juvenile with providing material support to a foreign terrorist organization, the attorney general would have to determine that the suspect committed what’s known as a “crime of violence” under federal law.

The Supreme Court struck down part of that law last year, finding it too vague to be enforced in the case of a Philippine man who was facing deportation over burglary convictions. Justice Neil Gorsuch joined the court’s more liberal judges, finding that the law crossed constitutional boundaries and that the law was not specific enough because it failed to adequately define what would be a violent crime.

“Vague laws invite arbitrary power,” Gorsuch wrote.

Facing only state charges, Azizi-Yarand struck a plea deal and was sentenced to 20 years in prison with the possibility of parole after 10. Prosecutors presented the case as an example of local and federal collaboration, but also said that the criminal charge that would have best fit Azizi-Yarand’s acts is unavailable in state court.

A charge of supporting a terror group “would’ve fit this crime better than the laws that we used,” Collin County District Attorney Greg Willis said in April.

After the Supreme Court ruling, the Department of Homeland Security said the decision “significantly undermines” its ability to deport people convicted of “certain violent crimes,” but the implications for terror cases weren’t immediately apparent.

It isn’t clear how many cases the Justice Department has handed off or dropped because of the Supreme Court ruling. The agency did not comment in response to multiple inquiries from The Associated Press.

Trying terrorism cases in state court can be problematic. Many states, including Texas, have no criminal statute against aiding a foreign terror organization. And, where such laws do exist, bringing state charges can complicate federal investigations.

Recommended For You

Commission Shortcut PRO* | 100% Done-For-You Affiliate Campaigns!

Commission Shortcut is YOUR shortcut to automated affiliate commissions in 3 simple steps! 100% Cloud based app and done-for-you campaigns!

Animaytor Diamond Personal | Ultimatum Video Creator

Animaytor Diamond Personal | Studio Quality 40 DONE-FOR-YOU Niche Templates with Image and Video, Powerpoint Style Videos, 1000 Transparent Images, 5000 Photos and Images, Customizable Video Scripts and Templates, 50 Borders, 60 Headers and Footers!

Freelance Revival

Freelancing is NOT DEAD! In fact, freelancing and remote work has now become a major and critical part of all businesses big and small. Freelancers can now have the opportunity to grow and thrive like never before. The future of all businesses will contin

Handling a case connected to terrorism can be a challenge for state prosecutors unschooled in radical ideologies, according to Seamus Hughes, deputy director of George Washington University’s Program on Extremism. “For state prosecutors it’s a learning curve,” he said. “You have to understand the nuances of ISIS ideology.”

This leaves federal law enforcement “in this strange limbo where either they kick it to a state level case or they track that individual until they turn 18,” Hughes said.

Prosecuting juveniles for terrorism is rare and the Supreme Court decision may have little impact on overall terror prosecutions because the decision makes it difficult to bring “a very narrow band” of terror cases, said Nick Lewin, a defense attorney and former federal prosecutor.

Davilyn Walston, a spokeswoman U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Eastern District of Texas, said depending on the facts of a case minors could be prosecuted as adults under other parts of federal law.

But “unless and until” Congress changes how “crime of violence” is defined in federal law the Supreme Court decision could continue to affect prosecutions, she said.

There’s no indication a change in legislation is imminent.

___

Bleiberg reported from Dallas.

___

Follow Bleiberg at twitter.com/JZBleiberg and Balsamo at twitter.com/MikeBalsamo1

Original Article : HERE ; This post was curated & posted using : RealSpecific

Recommended For You

Pixielogo Pro

Pixielogo Pro offers more templates, more icons and monthly templates free of charge to continue creating good looking logos for you and your clients.

Video Ads 2.0 Success Kit PLR

Get this Up-to-date "Video Ads 2.0 Success Kit" with PLR Rights and start cashing in huge by selling it as your own.

OneSoci Agency Toolkit - Done-For-You Emails, Ads, Posts, Scripts and More...

OneSoci Agency Toolkit - Done For You Client Getting Templates and Resources

Thank you for taking the time to read our article.

If you enjoyed our content, we'd really appreciate some "love" with a share or two.

And ... Don't forget to have fun!

Recommended

AdsCrisp Enigma Yearly Commercial

Unlimited Templates Club Access Plus and VidCrisp - Psychological Conversion Triggers!!

Stream Store Single (+Dynamic Posts Plugin)

Unlimited Commissions Having Each And Every Amazon Product Delivered On-Demand To Your Store! (+Dynamic Posts Plugin)

Leave a Reply